A Timely Reform by Ian Ridley

Blog & web site of Ian Ridley

Archive for the ‘Media’ Category

The Media Witch Hunt: The Truth Part 1

Monday, January 30th, 2006

All sorts of half-truths and plain lies are doing the rounds in the gutter press and broadsheets. Sometimes I think Murdoch has decided to be Witchfinder General trying to destroy the Lib Dems. The time has come to introduce a little Pravda.

Myth 1: The Scotsman reports, “Simon Hughes is now out of the running for the Lib Dem leadership after revelations about his sex life, rival Chris Huhne has said.”

The lack of a direct quote from Huhne is suspicious. In fact the actual quote in the article is:

“It’s a fact that in terms of the perceptions of both journalism and the bookies it is now effectively a fairly close race between me and Ming. So to that extent that is a consequence. But it certainly is not one that I sought and I had obviously moved ahead of Mark (Oaten) before all these revelations. This was something that I very much do not want to will on the party”

So the headline should have been, “Simon Hughes is now out of the running for the Lib Dem leadership after revelations about his sex life, according to bookies and journalists.“But that might be just too accurate.

Myth 2: The Liberal/SDP Alliance ran a homophobic campaign in the 1983 Bermondsey byelection. See the BBC and several broadsheets and tabloids over the past week.

The phrase “A Straight Choice” was a standard Alliance squeeze message and used in many seats at the time. An example of the same slogan in a different by-election can be found from the the Brecon campaign in 1985, two years later.

A two horse race is more usual nowadays (see Dunfermline & West Fife literature for up-to-the minute examples).

The homophobia is just another urban myth propagated by enemies of Simon and the Liberal Democrats.

A lot of the Bermondsey byelection literature from the Alliance can be found here. The phrase “A Straight Choice” was used just once in the context of a squeeze message on a leaflet.

Complaints about a G2V star

Thursday, January 26th, 2006

Is The Sun making a “pejorative reference to an individual’s …. sexual orientation” today?

Do bears……?

“Second limp-dem confesses”: looks pretty pejorative to me, as does the Caldwell “cartoon”.

An email to The Scum’s “Editor” is en-route. Followed by a complaint to the PCC.

PMQs: The Distracted Media

Thursday, December 8th, 2005

Whilst the new Tory leader grabbed the headlines trying to out-do Blair on selection for schools, an under-reported exchange took place between Charles Kennedy and the Prime Minister at PMQs yesterday (video feed – go to about 8 minutes in to see this bit) :

Mr. Charles Kennedy: …..to what extent, therefore, have the Government co-operated in the transport of terrorist suspects to Afghanistan and elsewhere, apparently for torture purposes?

The Prime Minister: …..The practice of rendition as described by Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice has been American policy for many years……However, it must be applied in accordance with international conventions, and I accept entirely Secretary of State Rice’s assurance that it has been.

Mr. Kennedy: Given that assurance, can the Prime Minister therefore explain why the published evidence shows that almost 400 flights have passed through 18 British airports in the period of concern? When was he as Prime Minister first made aware of that policy, and when did he approve it?

The Prime Minister: In respect of airports, I do not know what the right hon. Gentleman is referring to…..”

Am I the only one worried by this? Furthermore:

Bob Russell (Colchester) (LD): Why?

The Prime Minister: …..It is as well to remember that we need to detain some of the people we are talking about for reasons of action against international terrorism. Some of those people are highly dangerous, and some of them can provide information that is of fundamental importance in preventing terrorism. Of course, there should be proper treatment of anyone who is detained…. “

So why are these suspects being flown around the world, possibly to countries with questionable judicial processes and human right records? Something is not quite right here and if the UK is allowing these flights to use our airports then we are an accessory to human rights abuses.

Back to the C*m*r*n media love-in. I am astounded at what some of the TV channels are getting up to on this one. OK, so the above story got a spot on C4 news but they didn’t exactly make it clear that the Lib Dems had asked the question at PMQs – even though Kennedy was interviewed about it.

I tried to watch the repeat of PMQs usually available on BBC News 24 interactive or Sky News but all they had was the Blair-C*m*r*n exchanges. Back to the nice and easy imaginary two-party world that journalists like so much because it means they don’t have to think as much.

The item on PMQs during ITV’s “News” at Ten-something was so slanted to be biased in favour of the Tories that I’m sure it qualified as a PPB. Let alone the awful shallowness of the reporting.

I am more and more convinced that Chris Morris invented ITV News a decade ago. It was called “The Day Today”.